In this section we report on situations where a foreign government might have interfered with U.S. policies, elections, and other issues.
View our 99-second video outlining Trump's connections with Russia...
Click here for larger version
Related IssuesRussians' Secretive Deals with Donald Trump
WE NEED YOUR HELP
If this article helped your understanding, please consider a small donation to help us keep doing this.
It costs money to publish News in FiVe, and contributions are our only source of funding.
Even a dollar or three every so often makes a difference.
In return, we'll keep providing you the most relevant, understandable, and accessible news and information.
It's secure and takes only about a minute.
Stone indictment shows Trump campaign collusion - again
|2019-Jan-28||By: Rob Dennis|
In April 2016, hackers linked to Russian military intelligence stole tens of thousands of emails from the Democratic National Committee. Three months later, WikiLeaks released them.
Shortly after that, a high-ranking official for Donald Trump's presidential campaign "was directed" to contact Roger Stone, Trump's longtime friend and political adviser, to get information from WikiLeaks about any future releases or damaging information about Hillary Clinton's campaign.
All of that is according to a new indictment by Special Counsel Robert Mueller.
The charges against Stone
Stone was charged with obstructing investigations, lying to Congress and witness tampering.
From July to October 2016 Stone repeatedly reached out to WikiLeaks using intermediaries, according to the indictment. Those intermediaries are not identified in the indictment, but they have been revealed as right-wing political commentator Jerome Corsi and political satirist Randy Credico.
According to the indictment, Stone lied five times to the House Intelligence Committee, including saying that he didn't discuss his contacts about WikiLeaks with members of the Trump campaign.
"On multiple occasions, Stone told senior Trump Campaign officials about materials possessed by Organization 1 and the timing of future releases," the indictment said, referring to WikiLeaks.
The Russian connections
Stone had contacted Guccifer 2.0 - the hacker who had stolen the emails and provided them to Wikileaks. It now is known that Guccifer 2.0 was a Russian GRU officer.
This is at least the fifth publicly known instance of the Trump campaign seeking assistance from the Kremlin or its associates during the 2016 election, for both political and business reasons.
In all, Trump and his associates had more than 100 contacts with Russian nationals or WikiLeaks during the campaign and transition.
Note: The indictment does not identify the Trump campaign official who was directed to contact Stone. Nor does it identify who issued the direction.
Click here to read the indictment against Stone.
Trump hid details about Putin meetings
|2019-Jan-14||By: Rob Dennis|
President Donald Trump concealed details about his meetings with Russian President Vladimir Putin even from his closest advisers, the Washington Post reported.
2017: Hamburg, Germany
In at least one case, at the Hamburg G20 meeting in July 2017, Trump confiscated the notes from his own interpreter, who was ordered not to discuss what was said with other administration officials, the Post reported. Then-Secretary of State Rex Tillerson attended the meeting.
On the same trip, though, Trump met a second time with Putin with no American present, relying on the Russian president's interpreter.
The meetings came two months after Trump reportedly disclosed highly classified information to Russian officials in the Oval Office.
2018: Helsinki, Finland
In Helsinki in July 2018, Trump and Putin met for two hours with no aides or cabinet members present. No detailed record of the meeting was provided either to the public or to U.S. officials afterward.
"I'm not in a position to either understand fully or talk about what happened in Helsinki," Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats said four days after the meeting.
Aides are vital to national interests
Previous presidents had aides at such meetings to take detailed notes, which were later distributed to other senior officials. The practice prevents misunderstandings - or even deliberate distortions by an adversarial government - and allows the administration to follow up on any agreements.
Under Trump, there is no reliable record of his discussions with Putin, even in classified files, the Post reported. Officials sometimes have been forced to rely on reports by intelligence agencies tracking reaction in the Kremlin.
For more, read the Washington Post story.
FBI investigated whether Trump worked for Russia
|2019-Jan-14||By: Rob Dennis|
Has President Donald Trump been working for Russia against American interests?
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) began investigating that less than six months after Trump took office, the New York Times reported.
The counterintelligence investigation, which began days after he fired then FBI Director James Comey, sought to determine whether Trump "was knowingly working for Russia or had unwittingly fallen under Moscow's influence," and whether his actions constituted a threat to national security.
It was combined with a criminal investigation into whether the president had committed obstruction of justice by firing Comey. The decision to launch it was based in part on Trump's linking of the firing to the Russia investigation in a draft letter explaining Comey's dismissal and in a TV interview.
Special Counsel Robert Mueller was appointed shortly afterward to take over the investigation.
In an interview after the Times story was published, Fox News host Jeanine Pirro asked Trump if he is or has ever been working for Russia. Trump did not answer the question directly.
The following day, he did deny it.
For more, read the New York Times story.
Court filing reveals Trump campaign collusion with Russians
|2019-Jan-09||By: Rob Dennis|
President Trump's former campaign manager Paul Manafort shared campaign data during the 2016 election with a Russian tied to Russian intelligence, according to a new court filing.
Manafort and deputy campaign manager Rick Gates transferred polling data to longtime business associate Konstantin Kilimnik in the spring of 2016 as Trump clinched the Republican presidential nomination, the New York Times reported.
Information from poorly-redacted court document
The new details were revealed in a court filing by Manafort's lawyers, who were responding to prosecution claims that their client lied to special counsel Robert Mueller's office.
They had blacked out the information in order to redact it. They did it in such a way, however, that it could be revealed by simply cutting and pasting the text.
Timeframe overlaps Russian disinformation campaign
Some of the data was developed by a private polling firm working for the Trump campaign. Manafort asked Gates to tell Kilimnik to pass the data on to two Kremlin-supporting Ukrainian oligarchs, the Times reported.
Prosecutors claim Kilimnik has ties to Russia's military intelligence agency, the GRU. They claim he had such ties in 2016.
At the time Manafort and Gates were sharing the data, the GRU and businesses affiliated with the Russian government were engaged in a disinformation campaign to boost Trump and hurt his opponent, Hillary Clinton, prosecutors say.
Motives may have been personal
Manafort may have been trying to curry favor with Russian oligarch Oleg Deripaska, who has claimed that Manafort owed him millions of dollars for a failed business venture.
Deripaska, who is close to the Kremlin and associated with Kilimnik, has been accused of having ties to Russian organized crime.
In April 2016, Manafort asked Kilimnik in an email how they could use his prominent position with the Trump campaign to "get whole," apparently referring to Deripaska. In July 2016, Manafort emailed Kilimnik offering "private briefings" on the campaign for Deripaska.
Manafort also discussed a Ukrainian peace plan with Kilimnik during the campaign, according to the new court filing. It's unclear if it's the same pro-Russian plan brokered by Michael Cohen and Felix Sater, and presented to then-national security adviser Michael Flynn in the early days of the Trump administration.
Trump denies any knowledge of Manafort's actions.
"No I didn't know anything about it," Trump said.
Trump inaugural committee investigated for corruption
|2018-Dec-13||By: Rob Dennis|
Federal prosecutors are investigating whether donations to President Donald Trump's inaugural committee were in exchange for access and influence, the Wall Street Journal reported.
And whether some of those donors were from Ukraine and Middle Eastern countries.
They also are investigating whether the inaugural committee misspent some of the $107 million in donations it received. Much of the money came from donations of more than $1 million - from corporations and wealthy individuals.
Federal law prohibits buying influence. It also prohibits diverting funds from a nonprofit organization (the inaugural committee was registered as a nonprofit).
Foreign nationals are prohibited from donating to U.S. political groups.
In August, Republican lobbyist Sam Patten admitted as part of a plea agreement that he helped steer $200,000 in illegal foreign contributions to the inaugural committee, through a straw donation.
U.S. citizens are prohibited from knowingly making political contributions in another's name.
For more, read the New York Times story.
Lawyer: Trump offered Putin $50M penthouse in Moscow tower
|2018-Nov-29  (Updated: 2018-Nov-30)||By: Rob Dennis|
In the midst of his 2016 presidential campaign, Donald Trump's company planned to give Russian President Vladimir Putin a $50 million penthouse in a proposed Trump Tower in Moscow, Buzzfeed News reported.
The offer was part of the Trump Organization's efforts to reach a deal on the tower. That effort began three decades ago. And it continued deeper into Trump's presidential campaign than Trump or his associates had ever acknowledged.
Trump's former personal attorney Michael Cohen has now pleaded guilty to lying to Congress about when those negotiations were taking place. Cohen had testified that the project ended in January 2016 - before the Republican primaries had begun. In his plea bargain, he acknowledged they actually continued until June 2016 - after the primaries and around the time Trump formally received the Republican nomination.
Cohen also acknowledged other lies to the Senate and House intelligence committees:
Cohen, who served as Trump's personal attorney from 2007 to 2017, previously pleaded guilty to eight felonies in a separate federal case in New York.
In his Nov. 29 court appearance for this plea deal, he told the judge,
"I was aware of [Trump's] repeated disavowals of commercial and political ties between himself and Russia, his repeated statements that investigations of such ties were politically motivated and without evidence, and that any contact with Russian nationals by [Trump's] campaign or the Trump Organization had all terminated before the Iowa Caucus, which was on February 1 of 2016.
I made these misstatements to be consistent with [Trump's] political messaging and out of loyalty to [Trump]."
Throughout all of it, he had "regular contact" with Trump's legal team, Cohen said.
Manafort provided inside info to Trump on Mueller probe
|2018-Nov-28||By: Rob Dennis|
Paul Manafort's lawyer was providing inside information to President Donald Trump's attorneys even after Manafort was convicted and agreed to cooperate with the investigation into the campaign's ties to Russia.
Manafort is Trump's former campaign manager.
The arrangement was reported by the New York Times on Nov. 27 and acknowledged by one of the president's attorneys, Rudy Giuliani. It came the day after Special Counsel Robert Mueller said in a court filing that Manafort had violated his plea agreement by repeatedly lying about several subjects.
Giuliani claimed the arrangement was a way to obtain insights into Mueller's inquiry that could help shape a legal defense strategy, the Times reported.
Some legal experts have said Manafort's actions may mean he trying to obtain a pardon from Trump.
In an interview with the New York Post the day after the arrangement was revealed, Trump said a pardon for Manafort was "not off the table."
For more, read the New York Times story.
Russian charged with interfering in 2018 elections
|2018-Oct-19  (Updated: 2018-Oct-29)||By: Rob Dennis|
A Russian woman has been charged in connection with an alleged conspiracy to interfere in the U.S. election system, including this year's midterm elections. This is the first time prosecutors have alleged foreign interference in the 2018 elections.
According to the criminal complaint:
The complaint says the project advocated for or against candidates in 2016 and 2018. It also wrote about topics from "varied and sometimes opposing perspectives." Among them were...
Special Counsel Robert Mueller previously had charged 13 Russians, including Prigozhin, with the same alleged conspiracy regarding the 2016 election.
Trump adviser Papadopoulos to serve time in Russia probe
|2018-Sep-07||By: Barry Shatzman|
A former adviser for Donald Trump's presidential campaign has become the second person sentenced to prison in the investigation of the campaign's role in Russia's interference in the 2016 election.
George Papadopoulos was sentenced to 2 weeks in prison. In October of last year he pleaded guilty to lying to to federal authorities about his contacts with Russian operatives.
Investigators say that Papadopoulos' lies were especially damaging because they were made early in the investigation, and affected who would be interviewed.
The first person sentenced to prison in the inquiry was Alex van der Zwaan, a Dutch lawyer who also pleaded guilty to lying to investigators. Papadopoulos is the first adviser to the Trump campaign to be imprisoned.
For more, read the New York Times story.
Lawsuit could keep Mueller from sharing Trump-Russia findings
|2018-Aug-30||By: Barry Shatzman|
For more than a year Robert Mueller has been investigating what role Donald Trump's campaign played in Russia's interference in the 2016 presidential election. He's secured indictments, convictions, and the testimony of those in Trump's inner circle.
But he may not be able to tell anyone - including Congress - what he's learned.
The outcome could hinge on a court case that has nothing directly to do with the investigation.
Attorney and author Stuart McKeever has been investigating the disappearance of Columbia University professor Jesus Galindez in 1956. He is asking a federal court to release grand jury information on the disappearance. The Department of Justice (DOJ) is arguing that the secret information can be released only under specific exemptions.
If the court rules that the Galindez information cannot be released, it is possible the ruling could apply to Mueller's investigation also, meaning he wouldn't be allowed to release the information revealed by grand jury testimony. Not to the public, not to Congress.
With one exception. The House of Representatives could subpoena the findings in an impeachment inquiry.
For more, read the Politico story.
Did Putin say he ordered U.S. election interference?
|2018-Jul-30||By: Rob Dennis and Barry Shatzman|
If you watched President Donald Trump's July 16 news conference with Russian President Vladimir Putin, you heard Putin being asked if he wanted Trump to win the election and if had directed any of his officials to help Trump win it. And you heard Putin reply "Yes, I did. Yes, I did."
Putin didn't say that
That isn't what you really heard, of course, because you don't speak Russian. But even if you do speak Russian, that still isn't what you heard.
So what did you hear? According to native Russian speakers consulted by The Atlantic, what Putin said was, "Yes, I wanted him to win."
The administration didn't say that
The White House transcript originally omitted the first half of the question, so nowhere in it was Putin asked if he wanted Trump to win.
Also, the transcript only included the incorrect translation of Putin's answer. It omits Putin saying that he wanted Trump to win - even though that's actually what Putin said.
As of this writing, the administration has added the first half of the question back to the official transcript. But the incorrect translation of Putin's reply remains.
Much of the media didn't say that, either
National Public Radio (NPR) has the correct translation, but many other media outlets have failed to update theirs.
The Washington Post's transcript, obtained from Bloomberg Government, was updated to include the full question but not the correct answer.
As of July 25, a week after The Atlantic reported what Putin actually said, cable news hosts continued to erroneously repeat "Yes, I did. Yes, I did." Even Politifact misquoted Putin.
A CBS News article on the "correction" - accepts the administration's incomplete fix as complete.
What did Trump say?
On July 24, Trump told a veterans group not to believe what they're reading or seeing.
Russian with ties to NRA, Kremlin charged as foreign agent
|2018-Jul-18  (Updated: 2018-Jul-25)||By: Rob Dennis|
A Russian woman with deep ties to the National Rifle Association (NRA) has been indicted for her alleged role in a covert Russian influence operation in the United States.
Maria Butina allegedly worked with a high-level Russian official "to develop relationships with American politicians in order to establish private, or as she called them, back channel lines of communication," according to court records.
The pair also established relationships with American political organizations, including a gun-rights organization, according to court records.
The Russian official is not named in court records, but his description matches Alexander Torshin, a Russian banker and former Russian senator with close ties to the Kremlin. Torshin was sanctioned by the U.S. in April.
Spanish investigators have accused Torshin of laundering money for Russian organized crime figures when he served in the Russian parliament.
The FBI reportedly is investigating whether Torshin illegally funneled money through the NRA to support Donald Trump's 2016 presidential campaign. The NRA donated three times as much to Trump as they did to 2012 Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney.
Butina served as Torshin's unpaid special assistant from 2011 to 2017, according to her LinkedIn profile. The pair are lifetime members and active participants of the NRA - both in the U.S. and Russia.
Associations with Trump and other Republican groups
Shortly after Trump announced his candidacy in 2015, Butina asked him about U.S. sanctions on Russia at a conservative event.
Torshin tried twice to meet with Trump during the campaign, and did meet with Trump's son Donald Trump Jr. during a May 2016 NRA event.
Butina and Torshin also attended several events organized by Republican-linked groups, including two National Prayer Breakfasts.
In addition to her relationship with the Russian official, Butina was in contact with suspected Russian intelligence officers and two Russian oligarchs - one of whom is close to Putin - while she was in the United States, according to court records.
Butina's outreach to American political figures dates back years. She contacted an unnamed U.S. political operative in Moscow in 2013 who later arranged introductions to Americans with influence in politics, including the gun-rights group.
She developed a close relationship with longtime Republican Party activist and NRA member Paul Erickson. The two have known each other since 2013 and in February 2016 they formed the company Bridges LLC.
Erickson reportedly offered in May 2016 to set up a back-channel meeting between Trump and Putin through the NRA. Three months later, Butina obtained a student visa to attend American University in Washington, D.C.
After the 2016 election, Butina helped to set up a Russian delegation to the 2017 National Prayer Breakfast, saying in an email that it was an effort to "establish a back channel of communication," according to court records.
Butina also emailed a second unnamed U.S. citizen in 2016 and 2017 as part of her efforts to arrange "friendship and dialogue" dinners between Russians and influential Americans, according to court records. She wrote that a Kremlin representative had expressed approval "for building this communication channel."
After the 2017 National Prayer Breakfast, she thanked the second American in an email, according to the records.
"Our delegation cannot stop chatting about your wonderful dinner," she wrote. "My dearest President has received 'the message' about your group initiatives and your constructive and kind attention to the Russians."
Update 2018-Dec: Butina pleaded guilty to a conspiracy charge and admitted she had worked secretly with a Russian government official and an American to infiltrate U.S. conservative groups, including the NRA.
For more, read the Mother Jones timeline of Butina and Torshin's interactions with the NRA.
For more about the Butina indictment, read the New York Times story.
Click to view the following court documents regarding Butina...
Affidavit and Background
Request to keep Butina under detention
Trump meets Putin privately under shadow of indictments
|2018-Jul-16||By: Rob Dennis|
Three days after the Department of Justice indicted 12 Russian intelligence officers for meddling in the 2016 election, President Donald Trump stood side-by-side with Russian President Vladimir Putin and said he didn't "see any reason" the Kremlin would have done so.
"My people came to me, [Director of National Intelligence] Dan Coats came to me and some others, they said they think it's Russia," Trump said on July 16 after the two leaders met in Helsinki. "I have President Putin; he just said it's not Russia. I will say this: I don't see any reason why it would be."
Trump went on to say that he holds "both countries responsible" for deteriorating relations.
"I think that the United States has been foolish," he said. "I think we've all been foolish."
Pronouncement comes days after indictments of Russians
Special Counsel Robert Mueller on July 13 indicted a dozen members of Russia's military intelligence agency, the GRU, accusing them of hacking the campaign of Trump's Democratic opponent Hillary Clinton, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, and the Democratic National Committee.
Mueller previously had indicted 13 Russians and three Russian firms, accusing them of organizing social media campaigns and rallies to support Trump and other Clinton opponents.
Trump's July 16 statement contradicts not only Mueller's findings, but those of...
We don't know what Trump and Putin talked about in private, since only interpreters were present at the one-on-one meeting.
Similar meetings the year before
In July 2017, Trump and Putin had an hour-long discussion that the White House did not disclose. In that meeting, Trump and Putin were alone - with only Putin's interpreter present.
Zero spent of allocated $120M to stop election interference
|2018-Mar-04  (Updated: 2018-Mar-15)||By: Barry Shatzman|
Since late 2016, the State Department has had $120 million to investigate foreign attempts to influence U.S. elections. It has used none of it.
It has 23 analysts whose job it is to counter Russia's disinformation activities in the United States. None of them speaks Russian.
The lack of a Trump administration investigation comes in spite of...
Still, Trump has supported no actions to counter Russian activities.
He expressed doubt over the agencies' report, going as far as saying he believed Putin's denials.
After Mueller's indictments, his first response was not to express concern that elections were interfered with by a foreign government, but rather merely to claim in a Twitter posting that the Russian efforts started in 2014 - before Trump began his presidential campaign.
Regardless of the significance or insignificance of Trump's comparison - it is factually incorrect. He applied to patent his Make America Great Again campaign slogan in 2012.
Now-departing Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said in a Fox News interview that Russia is already attempting to interfere in the 2018 Congressional elections, but "if it's their intention to interfere, they are going to find ways to do that. We can take steps we can take but this is something that, once they decide they are going to do it, it's very difficult to preempt it."
On March 15, Trump did impose sanctions on Russia, but he stated they were in response to the killing of a former Russian spy in Britain. He did not mention election interference.
For more, read the New York Times story.
Indictment: American demonstrators duped by Russians
|2018-Feb-22||By: Rob Dennis|
In August 2016, grassroots groups supporting presidential candidate Donald Trump helped coordinate Florida Goes Trump rallies in the sunshine state.
One man was paid up to $1,000 to build a cage on a flatbed truck for the events, to be occupied by an actress in costume depicting Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton in a prison uniform. Another shared information about the rallies with contacts on social media.
The individuals and groups were American, but their instructions came from Russia.
These are among the claims in a 37-page indictment released Feb. 16 by Special Counsel Robert Mueller. The indictment accuses 13 Russians and three Russian businesses of conspiring to sow discord in the 2016 U.S. presidential election, including operations to support Trump, Clinton's Democratic primary challenger Bernie Sanders, and Green Party candidate Jill Stein.
What was in the indictment
The Internet Research Agency - one of the companies charged in the indictment - employed hundreds and had a monthly budget of up to $1.25 million (including money spent on projects aimed at a Russian audience). They tracked and studied social media dedicated to U.S. politics and issues starting in 2014.
The project was set up by Yevgeniy Prigozhin, a businessman with close ties to Russian President Vladimir Putin. These close ties - as well as his profession as a caterer - earned him the nickname Putin's chef.
They operated by setting up group pages on social media tackling issues ranging from immigration to Black Lives Matter, garnering hundreds of thousands of followers. It created hundreds of social media accounts, developing fictitious U.S. personas into "leaders of public opinion."
From April through November 2016, the operation bought online ads supporting Trump or opposing Clinton, using the stolen identities of real Americans and virtual private networks to conceal their origin. The ads also accused Clinton of voter fraud and encouraged minorities not to vote.
The operation organized rallies posing as U.S. grassroots activists, soliciting the unwitting support of genuine activists and low-level members of the Trump campaign. The rallies attracted anything from a handful to thousands of people. The Russian operation influenced a host of actions by Americans...
Facebook has deleted 470 accounts linked to the Internet Research Agency, which purchased 3,000 political ads. Up to 126 million people may have seen content posted by the group.
Trump 2017 real estate profit mostly from secretive buyers
|2018-Jan-16||By: Rob Dennis|
President Donald Trump's companies sold more than $35 million in real estate in 2017 - most of it to secretive shell companies, USA Today reported.
The use of shell companies in Trump's real estate deals increased dramatically around the time he secured the Republican nomination in mid-2016. In the two years before the nomination, only 4 percent of buyers used shell companies. In the year after, it was 70 percent.
Meanwhile, an investigation by BuzzFeed News found that more than a fifth of Trump condo buyers since the 1980s have used shell companies and paid in cash - two factors that can indicate money laundering.
One Trump project in particular stood out. At the Trump SoHo hotel in New York, more than three out of every four condo sales were to buyers using shell companies who paid cash.
The Trump SoHo deals, first reported by Lobby99 in August, included seven condos sold to Russian buyers. Moscow addresses on four of those deeds were crossed out, and replaced with the address of the buyer's attorney.
Profits from Trump's real estate deals go to a trust run by the president's sons. Trump is the sole beneficiary.
Testimony further debunks Trump dossier narrative
|2018-Jan-11||By: Rob Dennis|
Congressional testimony by the founder of the company hired to investigate President Donald Trump's connections to Russia has further debunked a false narrative attempting to discredit the findings of that investigation.
The testimony of Fusion GPS co-founder Glenn Simpson was released this week by Sen. Dianne Feinstein.
Trump, along with some Republican members of Congress and conservative media outlets, has been claiming that the FBI investigation into possible collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia was sparked by a "fake" dossier paid for by the campaign of 2016 presidential candidate Hillary Clinton.
There are three problems with the narrative, however...
Here's a timeline of how the investigation came about:
GCHQ, the British equivalent of the U.S. National Security Agency, alerts U.S. intelligence agencies about suspicious contacts between members of the Trump campaign and suspected Russian intelligence operatives. Over the next six months, other western intelligence agencies provide similar information.
Trump campaign foreign policy adviser George Papadopoulos drunkenly brags to an Australian diplomat that Russia had political dirt on Clinton.
2016, May or June
Fusion GPS hires Steele to explore Trump's connections to Russia.
2016, June 20
Steele issues his first report to Fusion GPS. He will produce 16 more through December 2016.
2016, May or June
Fusion GPS hires Steele to explore Trump's connections to Russia.
2016, Early July
Concerned that he might have uncovered a national security threat and "a crime in progress," Steele shows some of his early findings to an FBI agent. However, the New York Times reported, Steele's information "was not part of the justification to start a counterintelligence inquiry."
2016, July 7
Trump campaign foreign policy adviser Carter Page travels to Moscow to speak at the New Economic School. Page, who handed over unclassified documents to a Russian spy in 2013, delivers a speech criticizing the U.S. and other western democracies. The Trump campaign approved the trip, which "caught the attention of U.S. intelligence agencies."
2016, July 22
Wikileaks publishes about 22,000 emails stolen from the Democratic National Committee.
2016, July 25
The Daily Beast reports that the FBI suspects Russian government hackers stole the DNC emails. In response to this revelation, Australian officials tell their U.S. counterparts about Papadopoulos' claim two months earlier.
2016, July 27
Trump appears to call on Russia to hack Hillary Clinton's missing emails.
2016, Late July
The FBI opens a counterterrorism investigation into the Trump campaign's ties to Russia.
2016, Early October
A team of FBI agents interviews Steele about the information he has uncovered.
Click here to read our discussion of the Trump campaign's ties to Russia.
Flynn pleads guilty to lying to FBI, may testify against Trump
|2017-Dec-01||By: Rob Dennis|
Former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn has pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI, and reportedly has agreed to testify against President Donald Trump.
He is the first Trump administration official to be charged with a crime by special counsel Robert Mueller.
Flynn was charged with making false statements to the FBI in January - when he lied about his conversations with then-Russian ambassador to the United States Sergey Kislyak during the presidential transition the previous month.
Flynn also will testify that Trump "directed him to make contact with the Russians," ABC News reported.
In addition, the president's son-in-law Jared Kushner instructed Flynn to contact foreign officials on the United Nations Security Council to influence their vote on Israeli settlements, Bloomberg News reported.
Kushner previously had been co-director of a foundation that funded an Israeli settlement, Newsweek reported. He did not disclose that relationship on financial records he filed with the Office of Government Ethics (OGE).
Trump repeatedly has denied having anything to do with Russia, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary. In a February press conference, he specifically denied directing Flynn to speak with Kislyak about sanctions.
If Mueller can prove that Trump or Kushner directed Flynn to negotiate with the Russian government before taking office, they could be in violation of the Logan Act, which prohibits private citizens from conducting foreign affairs without the permission of the U.S. government.
Did Trump obstruct justice?
Flynn's testimony also could bolster an obstruction of justice case against the president.
Former FBI director James Comey wrote in a memo that Trump asked him to drop the Flynn investigation in February. After Comey refused to comply, Trump fired him. Trump acknowledged the firing was partly because of "this Russia thing."
Trump called Sen. Chuck Grassley the day after it was announced that the president's son Donald Trump Jr. would testify before Grassley's Senate Judiciary Committee. He pledged his support for one of the senator's key issues.
Trump reportedly was involved in drafting a misleading statement by Donald Jr. about a meeting during the campaign with a Russian lawyer with ties to the Kremlin.
Trump allegedly tried to persuade top Republican senators, including the chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, to end the Russia investigation, the New York Times reported.
In testimony before the House Intelligence Committee on Nov. 30, Attorney General Jeff Sessions refused to answer whether Trump ever asked him to obstruct the investigation.
For more on Flynn's possible violation of the Logan Act, read the Washington Post story.
Click here to read the charges against Flynn.
Click here to read the Statement of Offense against Flynn.
Click here to read Flynn's plea agreement.
Campaign aide told Trump about Russian connections
|2017-Oct-30||By: Rob Dennis|
A Trump campaign aide told Donald Trump in March 2016 that he had connections who could help arrange a meeting between Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin.
That is according to a plea agreement by the aid, George Papadopoulos, who has pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI. The plea was unsealed Oct. 30.
Papadopoulos learned in April 2016 that the Russian government had "dirt" on Trump's opponent Hillary Clinton from "thousands of emails," according to the agreement.
About a month later, Trump's son Donald Trump Jr. met with a Russian lawyer tied to the Kremlin who promised him damaging information about Clinton. The following month, WikiLeaks released nearly 20,000 emails stolen from the Democratic National Committee by hackers. U.S. intelligence agencies have stated they believe the hackers are connected to the Russian government.
Here's a timeline of how we got here...
2016, March 24
After he had been named foreign policy adviser to the Trump campaign, Papadopoulos met a London-based professor with ties to the Kremlin and a Russian woman he believed to be Putin's niece (she turned out to not be related to Putin).
After the meeting, Papadopoulos emailed a campaign supervisor and several other foreign policy advisers about the discussion, which he said was "to arrange a meeting between us and the Russian leadership to discuss U.S.-Russia ties under President Trump."
The campaign supervisor replied that he would "work it through the campaign," but that no commitments should be made. He added, "Great work."
The "campaign supervisor" is unnamed in the records, but the Washington Post reports he is Sam Clovis - Trump's national campaign co-chairman who now serves as senior White House adviser to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
2016, March 31
Papadopoulos attended a national security meeting with Trump and other foreign policy advisers. He introduced himself to the group by saying he had connections who could help arrange a meeting between Trump and Putin.
2016, April 26
The Kremlin-linked professor told Papadopoulos that the Russians had "dirt" on Clinton.
Over the next several months, Papadopoulos continued to try to set up a meeting between the campaign and the Russian government, and had multiple conversations with a man in Moscow who said he had connections to the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In addition to Clovis, Papadopoulos wrote to campaign manager Corey Lewandowski and campaign chairman Paul Manafort about his efforts, the Washington Post reported.
Clovis encouraged Papadopoulos and another foreign policy adviser to take a trip to Russia for meetings, although the trip never happened.
2017, July 27
Papadopoulos was arrested on suspicion of lying to the FBI for claiming his Russian contacts happened before he joined the Trump campaign. He has since been cooperating with investigators. He pleaded guilty Oct. 5.
2017, Oct 30
Papadopoulos' plea agreement was unsealed.
Earlier the same day, indictments against Manafort and associate Rick Gates on charges of money laundering and conspiracy were announced.
For more, read the Washington Post story.
Click here to read the indictment against Papadopoulos.
Click here to read the description of the charge against Papadopoulos.
Click here to read the plea agreement between Papadopoulos and the Department of Justice.
Former Trump campaign aides indicted for Ukraine deals
|2017-Oct-30||By: Rob Dennis|
Former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort and another campaign aide have been indicted on charges including money laundering and conspiracy against the United States.
Both Manafort and his associate - Rick Gates - have pleaded not guilty to the charges, which stem from Special Counsel Robert Mueller's investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election and potential collusion between the Trump campaign and the Russian government.
The 12-count indictment alleges that Manafort and Gates failed to disclose to the Department of Justice (DOJ) they were acting as agents of a foreign principal when they were paid to lobby for former pro-Russian Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych and political parties allied to him. They also are charged with filing false statements with the Justice Department.
The indictment also charges Manafort and Gates with hiding that money - tens of millions of dollars - from the government, laundering it through U.S. and foreign corporations, partnerships and bank accounts.
If convicted on all counts, Manafort and Gates could face decades in prison.
For more, read the New York Times story.
For more about Manafort and his ties to Russia, read the Lobby99 report.
For more about Manafort's involvement with the Trump campaign, read the New York Times story.
Click here to read the indictment against Manafort and Gates.
Trump attorney asked for Kremlin help on deal
|2017-Aug-29  (Updated: 2017-Aug-31)||By: Rob Dennis|
Felix Sater told Donald Trump's attorney in 2015 he could arrange a real estate deal with Russian President Vladimir Putin that would help Trump win the presidency.
Two months later, Michael Cohen - Trump's attorney and executive vice president for the Trump Organization - requested Putin's help developing a Trump Tower in Moscow, the Washington Post reported.
Cohen said in a statement to congressional investigators that he asked Putin's spokesman Dmitry Peskov for help at the recommendation of Sater - a longtime Trump associate who was convicted of assault and racketeering.
Sater also claims to have close relationships with the Russian government, and escorted Trump's children Ivanka and Donald Jr. on a 2006 Moscow trip to scout sites for a potential Trump-branded hotel. In emails to Cohen in late 2015, Sater wrote...
"Our boy can become president of the USA and we can engineer it. I will get all of Putins team to buy in on this, I will manage this process."
"I arranged for Ivanka to sit in Putins private chair at his desk and office in the Kremlin. I will get Putin on this program and we will get Donald elected."
Cohen wrote to Peskov using an email address for general press inquiries. He said in his statement that he did not recall receiving a reply, and that the Moscow project was dropped two weeks later.
Still, five months after that, Trump's son Donald Trump Jr., son-in-law Jared Kushner and campaign chair Paul Manafort met with Russians tied to the Kremlin in hopes of receiving damaging information about Hillary Clinton - his Democratic opponent in the election.
Investigators for Special Counsel Robert Mueller are "keenly focused" on what Trump knew about that meeting and whether he tried to conceal its true purpose, NBC News reported.
For more, read the Lobby99 summary of Trump's ties to Russia.
Trump's son met to get Russian government info on Clinton
|2017-Jul-10  (Updated: 2017-Aug-29)||By: Rob Dennis|
President Donald Trump's son met during the presidential campaign with a Russian lawyer tied to the Kremlin - who promised him damaging information about Hillary Clinton.
The meeting between Donald Trump Jr. and attorney Natalia Veselnitskaya took place at Trump Tower on June 9, 2016 - two weeks after Trump clinched the Republican nomination. Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner and then-campaign chair Paul Manafort also attended the meeting.
Also attending the meeting were Irakly Kaveladze, a Soviet-born financier who once was the focus of a congressional probe into money-laundering; and Rinat Akhmetshin, a Russian-American lobbyist and ex-Soviet counterintelligence officer who was involved in two hacking-related cases after working for Russian businessmen tied to Putin. Akhmetshin denies being involved in hacking.
Veselnitskaya's clients include people and companies close to the Kremlin. She has campaigned against the Magnitsky Act, a 2012 law passed by Congress to punish Russian officials believed responsible for the death of lawyer Sergei Magnitsky in a Moscow prison. Magnitsky had uncovered a scheme involving the laundering of millions of dollars into New York luxury properties by Russian mobsters.
Veselnitskaya is the family lawyer for Denis Katsyv, the son of a senior Russian official and owner of Prevezon Holdings - the Cyprus-based company accused in the laundering scheme.
A four-year investigation into Prevezon was led by U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara, who was fired by President Donald Trump in March. In May, the case was settled right before the trial was set to commence.
When the New York Times reported the Veselnitskaya meeting on July 8, Trump Jr. said in a statement that it focused on the adoption of Russian children by Americans - which had been barred by the Russian government in response to the Magnitsky Act.
Trump Jr. changed his story the next day to align with what three White House sources had told the New York Times - that he met with Veselnitskaya because she had offered "information that individuals connected to Russia were funding the Democratic National Committee and supporting Mrs. Clinton."
An email to Trump Jr. proposing the meeting has since been reported by the New York Times, stating that information was coming from a senior Russian government official and was "part of Russia and its government's support for Mr. Trump."
Trump Jr. replied, "If it's what you say I love it."
For more, read the New York Times report. Also read this Vox analysis.
For more on the Prevezon case, read the CNN story.
For more on the email to Donald Trump Jr. proposing the meeting, read the New York Times report
Special Counsel to investigate Trump-Russia connection
|2017-May-17||By: Rob Dennis|
The Justice Department has appointed former FBI Director Robert Mueller as special counsel to investigate possible collusion between President Donald Trump's campaign and Russia.
Mueller, a former prosecutor, served as FBI director from 2001 to 2013 under Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama. As special counsel, he will have the same powers as any U.S. attorney, including the authority to assign federal agents, issue subpoenas and prosecute crimes if needed.
The appointment was announced May 17 by Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, who has been overseeing the Russia probe after Attorney General Jeff Sessions recused himself.
Rosenstein announced Mueller's appointment the day after the New York Times reported that Trump had asked FBI Director James Comey in February to stop investigating former national security adviser Michael Flynn.
"I hope you can let this go," Trump told Comey, according to a memo written by the FBI director shortly after the meeting, the Times reported. The meeting took place in the Oval Office on Feb. 14, the day after Flynn was forced to resign.
Trump fired Comey on May 9. Initially, White House officials claimed Trump dismissed the FBI director on the recommendation of Sessions and Rosenstein.
However, in a subsequent interview on NBC Nightly News, Trump said he already had decided to fire Comey before he met with Sessions and Rosenstein. Trump also acknowledged that the firing was at least partly because of "this Russia thing."
For more, read the Washington Post story.
Trump discloses classified Israeli intelligence to Russia
|2017-May-15  (Updated: 2017-May-22)||By: Barry Shatzman|
President Trump disclosed highly classified intelligence to Russian officials in a May 10 White House meeting with them.
The intelligence disclosed by Trump - concerning a terrorist threat - could expose intelligence sources and capabilities - hindering the United States' ability to detect future threats, the Washington Post reported.
It said to have come from Israel. The New York Times reports that Israel previously had warned the United States about the sensitivity of the intelligence.
Administration officials initially denied Trump's disclosure of the information, but Trump later confirmed it himself via Twitter.
During a later visit to Israel, Trump also appeared to confirm the source of the intelligence as Israel.
Senate subpoenas documents on Russia
|2017-May-10||By: Rob Dennis|
The Senate Intelligence Committee has subpoenaed documents from former national security adviser Michael Flynn in connection with its investigation into Russian interference in the presidential election.
Flynn had refused the committee's initial request for the documents.
Flynn, who was forced to resign in February after his contacts with the Russian ambassador to the United States were made public, also is being investigated for accepting payments from Russia and Turkey.
The committee also has sent a series of document requests to other associates of President Donald Trump, including former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort and former campaign advisers Carter Page and Roger Stone. It has received only two responses - one of them from Page.
In addition, the committee has asked the Treasury Department for information related to Trump, his top officials, and campaign aides, Sen. Mark Warner told CNN.
The Treasury Department's criminal investigation division has been investigating allegations of foreign money laundering through U.S. real estate transactions.
Sen. Lindsey Graham, who is leading a Senate Judiciary Committee investigation, also said he wants to investigate business ties between Trump and Russia. In response, White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer said the president has "no connections to Russia," and that Trump has hired a law firm to write a letter to that effect.
White House refuses Congress' request for Flynn documents
|2017-Apr-25||By: Barry Shatzman|
The White House is refusing a House Oversight Committee request for documents related to former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn.
The documents involve payments Flynn received for speeches and lobbying in Russia and Turkey.
For more, read the BBC story.
Kushner omits Russian meetings on clearance application
|2017-Apr-06  (Updated: 2017-Jul-14)||By: Barry Shatzman|
President Trump's senior advisor and son-in-law Jared Kushner failed to disclose contacts with several Russians on his security clearance application, the New York Times has reported.
Kushner's contacts during the transition included Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak and Sergey Gorkov, head of the Russian state-owned bank.
The security clearance application requires the disclosure of all encounters with foreign officials in the past seven years, and warns that knowingly concealing material facts is a federal crime.
For more, read the New York Times story.
Update 2017-July-14: For an update, read this Business Insider story.
Rep. Nunes recuses self from Russia investigation
|2017-Apr-06||By: Rob Dennis|
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes has temporarily recused himself from the probe into Russian election interference while he is investigated for potential ethics violations.
The House Ethics Committee announced April 6 that it is investigating whether Nunes "may have made unauthorized disclosures of classified information, in violation of House Rules, law, regulations, or other standards of conduct" by speaking publicly about intelligence reports that he had viewed at the White House.
Nunes - a member of President Trump's transition team - becomes the third person associated with the president to relieve himself of authority related to the investigations into Russian influence in the administration. Attorney General Jeff Sessions recused himself from investigations, and National Security Adviser Michael Flynn resigned.
Rep. K. Michael Conaway now will head the Russia investigation, aided by Reps. Thomas Rooney and Trey Gowdy.
Nunes will continue to serve as chairman of the committee on matters unrelated to the Russia investigation.
For more, read the Washington Post story.
Info Nunes gave to White House came from White House
|2017-Mar-30  (Updated: 2017-Apr-03)||By: Rob Dennis|
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes received classified information from White House officials - and then returned to the White House to brief President Donald Trump about it, the New York Times reported.
Nunes then held a press conference outside the White House - describing his sources as whistleblowers.
The sources for the material were Ezra Cohen-Watnick, the National Security Council's senior director for intelligence, and Michael Ellis, a White House counsel attorney, the Times reported.
The Times reported that the information Cohen-Watnick and Ellis gave Nunes came not from intercepts of Trump aides, but from intercepts of foreign officials "talking about how they were trying to develop contacts within Mr. Trump's family and inner circle before his inauguration."
Nunes had served on the Trump transition team. Ellis worked for Nunes before joining the Trump administration. Cohen-Watnick was hired by former national security adviser Michael Flynn, who resigned after it was revealed that he had discussed sanctions against Russia with the Russian ambassador to the United States before Trump took office.
Flynn's replacement, Lt. Gen. H. R. McMaster, tried to remove Cohen-Watnick from his position, but Trump overruled McMaster after Cohen-Watnick appealed to senior adviser Steve Bannon and Jared Kushner, the president's son-in-law.
For more, read the Vox.com story.
House Intel Committee cancels Trump-Russia public hearing
|2017-Mar-27||By: Rob Dennis|
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes has cancelled a March 28 public hearing in the investigation into Russian interference in the November presidential election.
Nunes, who served on President Trump's transition team, announced the postponement of the hearing on Friday, after a week of revelations about the investigation and bizarre behavior by the committee chairman.
During the first public committee hearing on March 20, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Director James Comey confirmed that the FBI has been investigating Russian efforts to interfere with the presidential election since July, and that the probe includes possible collusion between Trump campaign members and the Russian government.
On March 22, after Comey's revelation, and one regarding former Trump campaign manager Paul Manafort, Nunes claimed a source showed him "new evidence" of inadvertent surveillance of Trump aides during the transition.
Nunes told House Speaker Paul Ryan about the evidence, convened a press conference, and then went to the White House to brief the president, without telling his fellow committee members. He later held another press conference outside the White House.
A Washington Post editorial suggested that Nunes, who has railed against classified leaks to the media, himself leaked classified information in those public statements.
Nunes himself noted that the surveillance was routine and legal, the kind of "incidental collection" that tends to happen when a person in the U.S. speaks with a foreign target of surveillance. This is reportedly how former national security adviser Michael Flynn's conversations with Russian envoy Sergey Kislyak were uncovered.
Other committee members say they still haven't seen the evidence. On Monday, Nunes acknowledged that he met the source of the information at the White House, increasing suspicion that he was merely acting on behalf of the Trump administration to distract from the investigation and bolster Trump's baseless claim that he was wiretapped by President Barack Obama.
Paul Manafort proposed influence plan to Russia 10 years ago
|2017-Mar-22||By: Rob Dennis|
In 2005, President Trump's former campaign manager Paul Manafort secretly worked with a close ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin on a plan to "greatly benefit the Putin government" by influencing politics, business dealings and news coverage in the United States and elsewhere," the Associated Press (AP) has reported.
Manafort proposed the plan to Russian oligarch Oleg Deripaska, a close ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin.
U.S. officials also are investigating Manafort's financial transactions in Cyprus, a country "once known as a haven for money laundering by Russian billionaires," the AP reported.
Those revelations were in addition to Manafort's previously disclosed work with Ukraine's pro-Putin former president, as well as with oligarchs in the former Soviet state. Ukrainian prosecutors want to question Manafort about his dealings there as part of a corruption investigation.
House Intelligence Committee to hold public hearing on Russia
|2017-Mar-07||By: Rob Dennis|
The House Intelligence Committee will hold its first public hearing later this month into alleged Russian interference in the November presidential election.
The initial witness list for the March 20 hearing includes...
It also will include representatives from CrowdStrike Services, the company that analyzed the hacking of the Democratic National Committee during the presidential campaign.
Absent from the list are current or former members of President Donald Trump's administration who met with Russian officials during the campaign or transition...
AG Sessions recuses self from Russia investigation
|2017-Mar-02||By: Barry Shatzman|
Attorney General Jeff Sessions has recused himself from investigations into whether Russia attempted to influence the 2016 presidential election.
During his confirmation hearings, Sessions testified that he had not met with Russian officials about Donald Trump's presidential campaign. It later was revealed that he had met with Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak.
For more, read the New York Times story.
Trump campaign aides had year-long contact with Russia
|2017-Feb-14||By: Barry Shatzman|
Associates of Donald Trump - including members of his campaign - had repeated contacts with senior Russian officials in the year before the 2016 election, the New York Times reported.
Phone records of the contacts were said to be obtained by U.S. intelligence agents.
There is no known evidence that the calls were used to cooperate in influencing the election, the Times states.
Nat'l Security Adviser Flynn resigns - what we know
|2017-Feb-13  (Updated: 2017-Feb-14)||By: Rob Dennis|
National Security Adviser Michael Flynn has resigned after it was revealed that he discussed Obama administration sanctions against Russia with the Russian ambassador before President Trump took office.
The Logan Act makes it a felony for unauthorized citizens to interfere in negotiations between the United States and foreign governments.
The Obama administration announced sanctions on Dec. 29, 2016 in retaliation for what intelligence officials said was Russian interference in the 2016 election to help Trump win the presidency.
The same day, Flynn discussed the sanctions with Russian ambassador to the United States Sergey Kislyak, according to the Washington Post. Officials who "routinely monitor the communications of Russian diplomats" said Flynn "urged Russia not to overreact" to the sanctions and made it clear that "the two sides would be in position to review the matter after Trump was sworn in as president."
The next day, Russian President Vladimir Putin announced he wouldn't immediately respond to the sanctions.
Over the next three weeks, White House officials, including Press Secretary Sean Spicer and Vice President Mike Pence, repeatedly denied that Flynn had discussed sanctions with Kislyak.
On Jan. 26, 2017, then-acting Attorney General Sally Yates informed White House Counsel Don McGahn that Flynn had in fact discussed sanctions with the Russian ambassador, contrary to the administration's denials. Trump was "immediately" informed of the issue. Still, Flynn retained his position for 17 days.
On Feb. 10, the day after the Post broke the story about Flynn's discussion of sanctions with Kislyak, Trump told reporters he was "unaware" of the report but would "look into that."
Just hours before Flynn resigned Feb. 13, Trump senior adviser Kellyanne Conway said the president had "full confidence" in his national security adviser.
For more, read The Guardian story.
U.S. Intel - Russia tried to influence election
|2017-Jan-06||By: Barry Shatzman|
U.S. intelligence agencies have determined that Russia conducted a deliberate attempt to influence the 2016 presidential election.
A report released by the U.S. intelligence community concludes that Russian President Vladimir Putin ordered the action - in an attempt to damage Hillary Clinton's campaign while helping Donald Trump's.